"When reputable scientists correct flaws in an experiment that produced fantastic results, then fail to get those results when they repeat the test with flaws corrected, they withdraw their original claims. They do not defend them by arguing irrelevantly that the failed replication was successful in some other way, or by making intemperate attacks on whomever dares to criticize their competence."

6 likes

Source: Mathematical Games. Scientific American (October 1973), later quoted in Roger B. Nelson Proofs Without Words: Exercises in Visual Thinking (Introduction, p. 5), 1993.

About the author

Martin Gardner

Mathematician

Martin Gardner was a mathematician and writer known for popularizing recreational mathematics and critical thinking through his influential works.

All quotes by Martin Gardner →

Same author

More quotes by Martin Gardner

See all →
Martin Gardner Mathematician

"The high number from the Middle East is only coincidence, he said. It is no particular choice on our part, ... We accept visa trainees from those countries. We'd accept them from other countries, too, but we don't get their applications."

Read quote
Martin Gardner Mathematician

"In many cases a dull proof can be supplemented by a geometric analogue so simple and beautiful that the truth of a theorem is almost seen at a glance."

Read quote
Martin Gardner Mathematician

"Wouldn't the sentence 'I want to put a hyphen between the words Fish and And and And and Chips in my Fish-and-Chips sign' have been clearer if quotation marks had been placed before Fish, and between Fish and and, and and and And, and And and and, and and and And, and And and and, and and and Chips, as well as after Chips?"

Read quote
Martin Gardner Mathematician

"If God creates a world of particles and waves, dancing in obedience to mathematical and physical laws, who are we to say that he cannot make use of those laws to cover the surface of a small planet with living creatures?"

Read quote
Martin Gardner Mathematician

"Biographical history, as taught in our public schools, is still largely a history of boneheads; ridiculous kings and queens, paranoid political leaders, compulsive voyagers, ignorant general the flotsam and jetsam of historical currents. The men who radically altered history, the great scientists and mathematicians, are seldom mentioned, if at all."

Read quote